As MLB The Show 25 continues to provide fans with an ever-expanding roster of legendary players, there are still a few iconic figures whose cards have yet to receive the coveted level 99 status. These players, who have earned their place in baseball history through impressive careers, are yet to be fully represented by the highest card rating in the game. Whether through outstanding batting, pitching, or fielding, these legends deserve a spot at the top, and fans are eagerly waiting for the day when their cards reflect their true greatness.
1. Bert Blyleven
Bert Blyleven was a dominant pitcher in the 1970s and 1980s, known for his devastating curveball and consistency on the mound. With over 3,700 strikeouts and a career ERA under 3.30, Blyleven was one of the most reliable and durable pitchers of his time. Despite his numerous accolades, including a World Series championship and a Hall of Fame induction, Blyleven has yet to receive a level 99 card in MLB The Show 25. His ability to dominate both left- and right-handed hitters with his curveball and fastball makes him a prime candidate for a 99 overall rating. Blyleven’s pitch repertoire and sustained success throughout his career would make him an incredible addition to any pitching staff in the game.
2. Keith Hernandez
Keith Hernandez was one of the premier first basemen of the 1980s, known for his exceptional glove work and on-base ability. A ten-time Gold Glove winner and two-time World Series champion, Hernandez’s defensive prowess at first base is still regarded as some of the best in history. While his offensive numbers may not match those of some other Hall of Fame players, Hernandez’s ability to get on base, his clutch hitting, and his leadership make him an integral part of any lineup. Despite his remarkable career, Hernandez has never received a level 99 card in MLB The Show 25. His defense alone should warrant a 99 overall rating, and his ability to consistently contribute offensively would make him a valuable asset in any version of the game.
3. Jim Edmonds
Jim Edmonds, a center fielder known for his spectacular defense and power at the plate, is another legend who has yet to receive a level 99 card in MLB The Show 25. Edmonds’ leaping catches and overall defensive ability were a sight to behold, and his bat complemented his glove with consistent power and run production. With eight Gold Gloves and over 300 home runs, Edmonds is one of the best all-around players to have ever played center field. His combination of elite defense, power, and speed makes him an ideal candidate for a level 99 card, but for some reason, he has not yet received this honor in the game. Edmonds’ versatility in the outfield and ability to hit for both average and power should make him a must-have player in the game’s lineup.
4. Alan Trammell
Alan Trammell, the Hall of Fame shortstop for the Detroit Tigers, was one of the most consistent and well-rounded players of his generation. A six-time Gold Glove winner and four-time Silver Slugger, Trammell’s ability to hit for average, hit for power, and play elite defense makes him a player who should easily earn a level 99 card. He was also a key player in the Tigers’ 1984 World Series championship, proving his ability to perform on the big stage. Despite all of his accomplishments, Trammell has yet to receive a 99 overall rating in MLB The Show 25. His defense at shortstop and ability to contribute with the bat make him a prime candidate for a level 99 card, and it’s long overdue.
5. Don Mattingly
Don Mattingly, a New York Yankees icon, was one of the most gifted hitters of the 1980s. A six-time Gold Glove winner and a leader for the Yankees, Mattingly’s consistent hitting and fielding ability make him one of the most underrated players in baseball history. Mattingly’s batting prowess, which included a .307 career batting average and a 1985 American League MVP award, should be reflected in the game with a level 99 card. His defensive play at first base and ability to drive in runs should make him a valuable asset in MLB The Show 25. Yet, despite his accomplishments and iconic status, Mattingly has never received a 99 overall card, leaving fans wondering when his excellence will finally be fully recognized.
Conclusion
While MLB The Show 25 offers a rich collection of legendary players, there are still a few icons whose greatness has not been fully recognized with a level 99 card. Bert Blyleven, Keith Hernandez, Jim Edmonds, Alan Trammell, and Don Mattingly are all deserving of this top-tier rating due to their impressive careers and impact on the game. From stellar pitching performances to gold-glove defense and clutch hitting, these players have earned their place in baseball history, and it’s time for their cards to reflect that. Hopefully, as the game continues to evolve, MLB The Show 25 will give these legends the recognition they deserve.